WNN INVESTIGATES UPDATE

Nolan Wells: No Indictments, But the Cause of Death Remains Undetermined

By Dee Daniels | Women’s Network News (WNN)
September 21, 2026

JACKSON COUNTY, Miss. — Nearly three months after 18-year-old Nolan Xavier Wells disappeared during a Fourth of July gathering on Mississippi’s Horn Island, a grand jury has reached a decision: no one will be criminally charged based on the evidence presented.

But one of the most fundamental questions surrounding Nolan’s death remains unanswered.

How did he die?

The Jackson County grand jury unanimously returned what is known as a “no true bill,” meaning jurors determined there was not sufficient evidence to establish probable cause for an indictment.

Jackson County District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath announced the decision Monday night.

The grand jury reviewed an extensive body of evidence, including testimony from 43 witnesses, 132 subpoenas, cellphone forensic reports, GPS information, photographs, videos and other investigative records.

The grand jury concluded it found no credible evidence that anyone traveling to or from Horn Island on the boats connected to Nolan’s trip engaged in criminal conduct related to his death.

But the decision requires an important distinction:

No indictment does not mean investigators determined precisely how Nolan died.

TWO AUTOPSIES — AND AN UNDETERMINED DEATH

Both Mississippi’s state chief medical examiner and the independent forensic pathologist retained by Nolan’s family classified his cause and manner of death as undetermined.

That remains significant.

The grand jury reported that the position, condition, time of discovery and location of Nolan’s body were consistent with drowning, and accidental drowning was not ruled out.

But “consistent with drowning” is not the same as a medical determination that drowning was the cause of death.

That distinction matters.

The independent autopsy previously commissioned by Nolan’s family also faced limitations because of decomposition and because the examination occurred after the original state autopsy.

Both examinations identified nonfatal bruising to the back of Nolan’s head. According to the grand jury report, a witness testified that Nolan had slipped awkwardly from the side of a boat but continued socializing afterward and did not appear seriously injured.

Investigators reported finding no fatal physical trauma.

WHAT THE GRAND JURY SAYS HAPPENED JULY 4

The grand jury report provides one of the most detailed official reconstructions yet of Nolan’s final known hours.

Nolan traveled to Horn Island aboard The Triton, one of three boats used by the group.

The Triton later experienced mechanical problems involving its bilge pump and motor and took on water while returning to the mainland. It eventually had to be towed.

According to the grand jury’s findings, Nolan chose to remain on Horn Island and continue socializing after the three boats departed.

His cellphone, however, returned to the mainland without him.

The report says Nolan was not the only person whose phone traveled back aboard a different boat.

Nolan was subsequently reported missing.

His body was found in the waters near Horn Island on July 6.

THE PHONE — ONE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT DROVE THIS CASE

From the beginning, Nolan’s cellphone became one of the central questions surrounding his disappearance.

His family publicly questioned why Nolan remained on the island while his phone returned to the mainland.

That question became part of a much larger investigation involving cellphone forensics, GPS information, photographs, video and witness testimony.

The grand jury ultimately reported finding no evidence in that material establishing criminal conduct connected to Nolan’s death.

RUMORS, RACE AND SOCIAL MEDIA

Nolan’s death generated national attention and intense speculation online.

Some accounts characterized the case as Nolan, who was Black, traveling to the island with three white friends who returned without him.

The district attorney disputed that characterization, saying Nolan traveled as part of a much larger group and encountered additional people on the island.

The grand jury reported finding no credible evidence that Nolan’s disappearance or death was racially motivated.

That finding addresses allegations raised during the investigation. It does not diminish the questions Nolan’s parents repeatedly raised while seeking an explanation for what happened to their son.

And it underscores another important lesson in this case: questions supported by evidence and allegations circulating on social media are not the same thing.

WHAT “NO TRUE BILL” ACTUALLY MEANS

The grand jury decision is consequential, but its legal meaning should be understood carefully.

It means the grand jury did not find sufficient evidence presented to it to establish probable cause for criminal charges.

It is not a criminal trial verdict, and no defendant was acquitted.

Mississippi has no statute of limitations for homicide.

The grand jury itself acknowledged that if credible evidence emerges in the future suggesting Nolan’s death was not accidental, the matter could be presented to another grand jury.

For now, however, the criminal investigation has reached its most significant turning point since Nolan's body was recovered.

WHAT REMAINS UNANSWERED

The investigation has answered several important questions.

Authorities say they found no evidence establishing criminal wrongdoing. They found no fatal physical trauma. The grand jury found no credible evidence supporting claims that Nolan’s death was racially motivated.

But one central medical finding remains unchanged:

Nolan Xavier Wells’ cause and manner of death are undetermined.

That leaves a narrower—but deeply important—question.

If Nolan's death was accidental, exactly what happened after he remained on Horn Island?

Who last saw him?

When was he last known to be alive?

And what happened between that moment and the discovery of his body two days later?

Those questions are different from asking whether prosecutors currently have evidence sufficient to charge someone with a crime.

For Nolan’s parents, Christine and Elmore Wonsley, the search has always centered on knowing what happened to their son.

The grand jury has now provided an answer to one question:

Based on the evidence presented, there will be no criminal indictments.

It has not provided a definitive answer to another:

Exactly how did Nolan Xavier Wells die?

That distinction is where this case stands tonight.

WNN Investigates will continue following official records, statements from the Wells family and their attorneys, and any new evidence that could materially change the findings in this case.

Women’s Network News — Breaking Credible News, one story at a time.